Share the wealth! Refer your colleagues to the FORTUNE Education Program.
This week's cover

The FORTUNE Preview Guide

A biweekly guide produced for members of the FORTUNE Education Program.

"The Tragedy of General Motors"

Cover Date: February 20, 2006
Note: The FORTUNE Preview Guide is created in HTML. If you are unable to properly view the cover image, Course Connector, or hyperlinks, please view the online version at http://www.fortuneeducation.com/preview_guides/index.html.

COURSE CONNECTOR
http://www.fortuneeducation.com/preview_guides/images/fep_20060206_cc.jpg

ARTICLE SUMMARIES AND QUESTIONS
"The Tragedy of General Motors," pp. 58-75: While it's almost unthinkable that business giant General Motors could declare bankruptcy, it is a very real possibility for the troubled company. For GM, which held the top spot on the FORTUNE 500 for 37 out of 50 years (it was most recently listed at No. 3), its massive size — and that of many of its products — is its biggest problem. The company currently pays the health costs for a staggering 1.1 million employees, retirees and dependents, and it compensates thousands of laid-off union workers to the tune of $100,000 each annually. Meanwhile, its U.S. product mix, heavily weighted toward bulky, gas-guzzling trucks, pickups and SUVs, is on the wrong side of gas prices. Although the quality of GM products has been substantially and indisputably improved over the years, the company still battles an image of poor craftsmanship among American consumers that has helped reduce its market share to 26%. To offset its losses, GM has closed plants, terminated jobs, reduced engineering and parts costs, and even put its finance subsidiary, GMAC, on the market. But no company has ever turned around because of cost cutting alone. The company will only survive by increasing its revenues. Left to this monumental task is GM's almost irrationally positive chairman and CEO, Rick Wagoner, who has vowed that the 98-year-old company will not go under on his watch.

Students will analyze the myriad problems facing auto industry giant General Motors and the last-ditch strategic plans its managers hope will turn the company's fortunes.

Discussion Questions:

  1. In 2005, General Motors' finance subsidiary, GMAC, earned profits of $2.83 billion and paid $2.5 billion in dividends to its parent company. Why then is GM seeking to sell its majority interest in GMAC? If a buyer is found, how will the sale impact GM's bottom line?


  2. The article states, "The truth is that GM is essentially indentured to the UAW because of the union's power to strike." In what ways does the United Auto Workers union in large part control GM's destiny? If you were GM's union negotiator, how would you persuade the union to work with the company in its attempts to gain cost savings and remain solvent?


  3. Explain why GM is embroiled in the bankruptcy of auto-parts maker Delphi. In your opinion, can GM, Delphi and the UAW each emerge from the crisis with its respective needs met? Why or why not?

"Who Wants to Be the Boss?" pp. 76-78: Why would anyone want to be a CEO in the 21st century? Sure, it was never an easy job, but CEOs of yesteryear could at least expect to turn the crank on a good business model for a few decades. Not so for today's CEO, who must manage a constantly changing business model, thanks to the information-based economy. Speaking of information, both customers and investors have a lot more of it these days, and since knowledge is power, companies and the people who lead them are left to grovel. Even employees have cut into the corporate chief's clout — as the Baby Boomers retire and highly skilled employees become harder to find and retain, CEOs have to bend to meet the increasing demands of younger workers. Add to all these pressures the proliferation of global competition and you've got one big pair of corporate shoes to fill. Miraculously, there are still people willing to step right into them. Of course, not every company gets a fairy-tale ending. Some jobs prove too tough, and the companies involved become sad stories of decline. But in other cases, a fearless CEO takes on a situation that seems hopeless and gets the job done, producing spectacular results for investors.

This article shows how the role of CEO has become more demanding as the world economy grows and evolves.

Discussion Questions:

  1. What do you think is the single biggest challenge facing CEOs today? In your opinion, what management skills are most essential for successfully guiding a company through this dilemma? Why?


  2. How do increased customer power and investor power make the CEO's job more difficult? Can they serve as an asset to a company? Explain.


  3. What makes the job of CEO more desirable today than in years past? Less desirable? Are the rewards of the job commensurate with the progressively arduous nature of the work involved?

"The Best Investor of His Generation (So What Is He Doing with Sears?)," pp. 90-104: There's no question that Eddie Lampert is one heck of an investor. Set up by the legendary Richard Rainwater with his own fund to run at the tender age of 25, Lampert has built his ESL Investments into a $15 billion powerhouse that has outperformed Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway during its 18-year lifespan. But plenty of heads were scratched in 2004 when Lampert acquired Sears. What did the phenom see in the venerable but troubled retailer? Many skeptics surmised that Lampert viewed Sears as a kind of personal ATM, from which he could merely pull cash to invest in the next addition to his hedge fund. But that's looking more and more like a misconception. While his official title is chairman, Lampert operates much like a CEO, calling the shots on strategy, marketing and merchandising. He spends hours at his Connecticut office analyzing sales, margins and inventory data, zeroing in on whatever isn't making money. Clearly, he wants to rebuild Sears into a great company again. That's no surprise considering he controls an $8 billion stake in its future. Whether he is successful in this venture remains to be seen, but if his investment record is any indication of his prospects — his hedge fund has delivered average annual returns of nearly 30% after fees since its launch — look for Sears to become the next great comeback story.

In this article, students will take a closer look at one of the top young investors and his strategy for turning around an aging colossus of American retail.

Discussion Questions:

  1. How did Eddie Lampert's prior experience with acquiring and reviving Kmart influence his decision to do the same with Sears? How did he use Kmart to orchestrate his takeover of Sears?


  2. How did Lampert's 2003 kidnapping help enable him to attain sole control of Kmart and Sears?


  3. In your opinion, will Sears Holdings ultimately produce the kind of aggressive returns to which Lampert is accustomed? Why or why not?

"Deadly Caution," pp. 107-120: The recent, well-publicized withdrawal from the market of such frequently prescribed drugs as Vioxx and Bextra — and the resulting lawsuits filed against pharmaceutical manufacturers by affected patients and family members — would seem to suggest that the Food and Drug Administration isn't doing such a bang-up job of testing prescription drugs before approving them for use. So why are advocacy groups springing up to argue just the opposite — that our national obsession with drug safety is killing more people than it saves? Partly out of desperation and partly because the numbers seem to suggest it is so. Patients with life-threatening illnesses often don't have time to wait for a developmental drug to be fully tested and approved, and they are willing to accept the risks involved in taking an experimental drug if it offers hope for a cure. Activists contend that the number of patients who could be saved during an effective drug's trial period, which can last 10 years or more, is far greater than the number who are harmed if a potentially hazardous drug somehow makes it to market. Stuck in the middle of this passionate debate is the FDA, which has the almost impossible job of approving drugs "rapidly, but not recklessly." Unless it can work together with Congress, Big Pharma, doctors and patients to mend the flawed drug review process, don’t expect it to change monumentally anytime soon.

Students will look at the factors that affect drug review and approval, and consider differing viewpoints on whether the process needs an overhaul.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Why is the FDA hesitant to release experimental drugs to terminally ill patients? What problems are regulators trying to avoid?


  2. What is Bayesian analysis? How could it help improve the FDA's current drug review process?


  3. How does the RotaShield incident ironically tend to support arguments for a speedier release of promising drug vaccinations and therapies?
Share the wealth! Refer your colleagues to the FORTUNE Education Program.

Visit Our Website for Program Benefits

The FORTUNE Preview Guide is a biweekly publication of the FORTUNE Education Program, and is designed to provide professors with the necessary resources to use FORTUNE Magazine in the classroom. The FORTUNE Education Program also invites professors and students to subscribe to FORTUNE Magazine for less than than $1 an issue. Visit our Website at http://www.fortuneeducation.com.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?
This is your FORTUNE Preview Guide. What do you want to see in it? Send your comments or suggestions to fortune@fortuneeducation.com.

CHANGE YOUR SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS
The FORTUNE Preview Guide is available by e-mail only. Current and archived issues also are available online at http://www.fortuneeducation.com/preview_guides. To notify us of an e-mail address change, please call 800-416-5138 or send an e-mail to fortune@fortuneeducation.com with a complete description of your request. Any changes made will not affect your magazine subscription.

CONTACT US
If you want to know more about the FORTUNE Education Program, or would like to subscribe to FORTUNE Magazine and receive 85% off the cover price, please call 800-416-5138 or visit our Website at http://www.fortuneeducation.com.

The FORTUNE Education Program is available only to subscribers in the U.S. and Canada.
© 2006, FORTUNE Education Program Read our Privacy Policy
www.fortuneeducation.com